They did not want this to happen.
The historic West Park Presbyterian Church in Manhattan, New York, faced the prospect of demolition due to financial difficulties. However, objections from local residents and celebrities like Matt Damon and Mark Ruffalo resulted in a temporary halt to the plans. The 133-year-old church, aiming to sell the property for luxury apartments, encountered challenges due to its landmark status, requiring approval from the Landmarks Preservation Commission for demolition.
The withdrawal of the demolition application occurred just before the commission’s vote, influenced by a lawsuit related to a lease dispute with a tenant. Despite this setback, the church expressed its intention to resubmit the application after resolving the litigation. In 2022, church leaders had entered into a contract with a condominium developer due to a $2 million repair bill, with plans to de-landmark and demolish the building for the condominium, which included worship space.
City Council Member Gale Brewer expressed optimism that the delay might lead to the preservation of the historic site. However, amidst New York City’s housing crisis, some argue that opposition to the church’s demolition may hinder essential housing development. Marsha Flowers, a ruling elder of the West Park Presbyterian Church, conveyed frustration with financial challenges and highlighted the congregation’s focus on creating a new space for worship and the arts.
Prominent figures such as Matt Damon, Wendell Pierce, Amy Schumer, and Common have thrown their support behind the preservation effort. Damon, in particular, participated in a play performance at the church in November as part of the campaign. The situation of the church underscores the complex interplay between historic preservation, financial constraints, and the ongoing need for housing solutions in the city.