They are losing their way.
Theologian and author John Piper has voiced strong opposition to the use of artificial intelligence platforms like ChatGPT for writing sermons, expressing that he was “appalled” by the idea. During Monday’s episode of “Ask Pastor John,” listeners inquired about using AI platforms such as ChatGPT to assist in crafting sermons or Bible studies.
Piper explained that AI lacks the emotional depth required for true worship, stating that God is not only glorified through logical understanding but through genuine feelings of admiration, joy, and awe. He emphasized that worship involves emotions, which computers cannot replicate. Piper referred to emotions like rejoicing, grieving, and being amazed as uniquely human, noting that “artificial emotion” is a contradiction in terms.
While Piper acknowledged that AI can be useful for gathering information, he strongly opposed the idea of using AI to draft sermons or church newsletters unless proper credit was given to the platform. He warned pastors not to rely on AI for sermon composition, insisting that the ability to interpret scripture and convey the emotions it is meant to evoke is a critical gift for any church leader.
Piper referred to 1 Timothy 3:2, which outlines the qualifications for church leaders, particularly the ability to teach. He argued that pastors must have the skills to understand scripture, communicate it clearly, and apply it for the spiritual growth of others. He further emphasized that if AI is used in sermon creation, it should be openly acknowledged.
In recent years, some churches have experimented with AI in various capacities, such as providing informational tools or writing sermons. For instance, the Toronto United Church Council and the TryTank Research Institute developed “AskCathy,” an AI chatbot designed to answer questions about The Episcopal Church. However, Rev. Lorenzo Lebrija, executive director at TryTank, stressed that AI should never replace human interaction, seeing it instead as a tool to enhance the work of the church.