The pastor in question was fired.
The Free Church of England has terminated the Rev. Brett Murphy, citing that the “nature and tone” of his anti-woke YouTube videos, which included derogatory references to progressive female clergy as “witches,” harmed the church’s reputation. This decision comes even though Murphy successfully grew his congregation at Emmanuel in Morecambe from two to 50 members during his time there.
Murphy, who holds conservative views on various social and religious issues, defended his comments as sarcastic critiques of what he perceives as extreme feminism in the church rather than a direct attack on women in ministry, according to reports from The Telegraph.
The church’s disciplinary ruling acknowledged Murphy’s assertions about free speech but emphasized that there are limits when it comes to safeguarding the church’s image. The ruling noted that while Murphy might present his views as personal, they inevitably reflect on the Free Church of England (FCE).
Additionally, the ruling confirmed accusations that Murphy had not adhered to directives from his bishop and had mismanaged church finances. It highlighted his “inappropriate online activity” as inconsistent with the church’s values. Murphy faced criticism for using FCE branding in his videos, which blurred the line between personal and organizational views.
In response to the allegations, Murphy described the investigation as unjust and likened the process to a “kangaroo court.” He expressed his distress over being dismissed via email after what he called a “traumatic” 13-month tenure, which he felt negatively impacted his family.
Murphy also claimed that Bob Stephen, the FCE general secretary, played multiple roles in the investigation, which he argued violated the FCE’s own protocols that require a panel of both clergy and laypeople to address accusations against ministers.
Andrea Williams, Chief Executive of the Christian Legal Centre, criticized the FCE’s decision, arguing that a vibrant Christian community should celebrate leaders like Murphy who foster growth and engagement. She pointed out the cruelty of uprooting Murphy and his family from their church.
Despite a previous exoneration by a Church of England tribunal for comments made about its first trans-identified archdeacon, Murphy’s alignment with the FCE, a conservative Anglican group associated with Gafcon, marked a notable departure from the Church of England.
In light of his dismissal, Murphy is considering starting a new church, supported by over £140,000 in donations he received online. He believes this new venture could allow him to continue his ministry without the constraints imposed by the FCE.
During an interview on the YouTube channel Lotuseaters, Murphy highlighted the growth and diversification of his congregation, noting a significant increase in younger members and new church activities, such as youth groups and Bible studies, all developed within his first year. He speculated that his success may have threatened the authority of his bishop, who he described as resistant to scrutiny and transparency.